Shoes! Shoes! Shoes!

I've never been a shoe girl. For the past few years I've lived in Crocs brand ballet flats like these:
This year I've updated my shoe wardrobe slightly. I've added fit flip boots (for those cold VA nights), a pair of FRYE brown boots, and som MBT walking shoes. Waahoo. Look at me go. What I need now is a pair of shoes to go with my bridesmaid dress for the wedding.

I'm currently deciding between these two little beauties at Kate Spade:

What do you think? Yay? Nay? Suggestions?